Who Pays for the Sale · Part 5 of 7
The Rules Are Written Without Us
For more than 15 years, the rules for listing photos have been written by NAR committees, MLS boards, data-standards groups and state legislatures. In the public records we reviewed, photographers didn't have a seat at any of those tables.
By Kennith Wheeler, Founder, Respeno · Published November 10, 2026 · Sources checked November 10, 2026 · 3 min read
This isn't a story about bad people. It's a story about who's in the room. When the people writing the rules all sell, license or host listings, the rules end up serving those who sell, license and host listings.
Who wrote the rules
| Year | Where | What happened | Photographers in the room? |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | NAR MLS committee | Approved letting MLSs require up to 50% of the copyright in "certain listing content" | None found |
| 2025 to 2026 | CRMLS | Wrote its altered-image rule; its FAQ names REimagineHome, made by a company Venture MLS invested in, as an example tool | None mentioned |
| 2025 | California legislature (AB 723) | Passed altered-photo disclosure; the committee analyses list the state Realtors association in opposition and no photographer group on either side | None listed |
| 2025 | Wisconsin legislature (Act 69) | Registered lobbyists for the bill: the state Realtors association, Zillow and the title association | None registered |
| 2023 | RESO media standards | Presenters came from an MLS software company and two MLSs; the data standard has a field for photo alteration but none for photographer credit or copyright | None found |
| 2016 | NAR MLS committee and Board | Rewrote the MLS content policy after lawsuits; the Board vote was reported as passing "overwhelmingly without discussion" | None mentioned |
| 2012 | NAR legal guidance | Advised MLSs hiring photographers that, if cost allows, getting all rights is preferred | Not consulted |
In 2016, the chair of NAR's MLS committee acknowledged that photographers were pushing back and planned to talk with local photographers. We found no public record of what came of it.
Who invests in the vendors
The same groups that write the rules also back the companies those rules send business to.
- Venture MLS was launched by CRMLS's leaders, with CRMLS's CEO and controller among its fund managers. It invested $1 million in Styldod in 2022. CRMLS then rolled Styldod's AI staging tool out to more than 100,000 users. Press coverage says portfolio companies get access to CRMLS subscribers and staff support. We found no public conflict-of-interest policy.
- Second Century Ventures is NAR's wholly owned investment arm. Its REACH program has included photo editing and AI image companies. More on that in Part 6.
To be fair
NAR has also taken positions that protect content creators:
- Its 2016 policy barred MLSs from requiring brokers to give up ownership. The November vote moves away from that.
- NAR's legal team has told agents to disclose AI-altered photos.
- In 2025, NAR told the White House that AI development should protect copyrights, "including those for listings, photos."
Those positions matter. They also show NAR knows the photos have owners. The owners just aren't part of the conversation.
Why photographers aren't there
Part of the answer is on us. Real estate photographers are mostly small, independent businesses. We haven't organized. Professional photography groups have filed briefs in court cases, but we found no published position from any of them on MLS photo licenses or the new disclosure laws.
That silence gets filled by whoever is in the room.
What media companies can do now
- Read your MLS's photo rules. Know what your agents are granting on your behalf every time they upload.
- Write your license terms down. Put them on every invoice and delivery: who can use the photos, for what, and for how long.
- Organize. Join ASMP, the American Society of Media Photographers, or another group that advocates for photographers' copyright, and ask it to take a position on MLS licenses and NAR's new policy.
- Speak up locally. Ask your MLS and your Realtor association to include photographers when they write rules about photos.
- Comment publicly. When states propose photo-disclosure laws, submit comments. In the records we found, photographers have never been listed.
Sources
Sources checked November 8 to 10, 2026.
- 2026 policy: NAR, November 8, 2026.
- CRMLS altered-image FAQ: CRMLS, 2026. REimagineHome rollout: CRMLS, January 2025.
- AB 723 committee analyses: Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection and Senate Judiciary.
- Wisconsin AB 456 lobbying: Wisconsin Ethics Commission.
- RESO media standards: RESO, June 2023 and RESO Data Dictionary, Media.
- 2016 policy change: Inman, May 2016 and REALTOR AE, July 2016.
- 2012 guidance: NAR, Copyright Considerations for MLS Photographs.
- Venture MLS: RISMedia, April 2022 and PR Newswire, June 2022.
- Second Century Ventures: NAR.
- NAR on AI and copyright: NAR, October 2025. AI disclosure guidance: NAR, November 2022.
- Photographer organizations in court: NANPA on the VHT v. Zillow amicus brief, August 2022.
How we source and date figures: Respeno sourcing standards.
This post is the author’s analysis and opinion. "None found" means we found no record in the public sources listed; it doesn’t prove no photographer was ever consulted.
Free for real estate media companies
The License Terms Kit
What to put in your photo license, what NAR’s November 8 MLS copyright policy means for you, what Zillow and Aryeo take when you upload, and the disclosure laws for edited photos. Plain language, sourced, and ready to use today.
We send one confirmation email first. After that, occasional articles for media companies. Unsubscribe any time. No cookies. Privacy.