Who Pays for the Sale · Part 4 of 7
Who Owns the Photos You Paid For
Under federal law, the photographer owns the listing photos the moment they're taken. Everyone else, from the agent to the MLS to the portals, works under a license. On November 8, NAR's MLS committee voted to let MLSs ask for up to half of the ownership.
By Kennith Wheeler, Founder, Respeno · Published November 10, 2026 · Sources checked November 10, 2026 · 4 min read
Most sellers assume the photos of their home belong to them, or to their agent. Most agents assume the MLS has it handled. The law says something simpler.
What the law says
- The creator owns it. Copyright belongs to the person who made the work, from the moment it's made (17 U.S.C. §201).
- A transfer needs a signature. Ownership only moves to someone else through a written document signed by the owner (17 U.S.C. §204).
- Everyone else gets permission. An agent who hires a photographer normally gets a license: permission to use the photos for marketing that listing. The seller usually gets nothing in writing at all.
What the MLS asks for
When an agent uploads photos, the MLS asks the agent to grant it rights, often far broader than the agent's own license from the photographer.
- CRMLS, the largest MLS in the country, requires rights that are "irrevocable, unrestricted, transferable, perpetual, royalty-free, non-exclusive, and with the right to sublicense."
- Other MLS upload terms have claimed the right to modify the photos and strip out their embedded information, which is where a photographer's name and copyright notice live.
- An agent can't grant more than they have. If the photographer licensed the photos for one listing, the agent can't hand the MLS a perpetual license to do anything with them.
CRMLS's own photographer program shows what's at stake: it says agents need the photographer's written permission before reusing photos for a later listing.
The rule that just changed
In 2016, NAR's MLS policy said brokers "cannot be required to transfer any ownership rights (including intellectual property rights)" to the MLS. That protected brokers, and by extension the photographers whose work they license.
On November 8, 2026, NAR's MLS committee approved a change. MLSs may now require "an ownership interest of up to 50%" in the copyright of "certain listing content," with quarterly copyright registration and a chance for brokers to opt out. NAR's announcement points to listing data and images being "increasingly distributed across third-party platforms." It doesn't define "certain listing content," doesn't say whether photos are included, and gives no effective date.
A broker can't assign a share of something the broker doesn't own. If photos are included, the pressure lands on photographers to sign over ownership, so the broker can pass half of it to the MLS. Nobody asked the photographers.
What the courts have said
- VHT v. Zillow: a real estate photography company sued Zillow over photos used on a Zillow site. In 2023 the appeals court ruled that each photo was its own work for damages, which kept damages at $800 per image on about 2,300 images.
- Stross v. Redfin: in 2018 an appeals court reversed a win for Redfin, ruling that Redfin couldn't lean on the MLS's agreements unless those agreements clearly meant to cover it. The case went back to the lower court, and its final outcome isn't public in the records we found.
- CoStar v. Zillow: CoStar, which employs its own photographers, is suing Zillow over tens of thousands of listing photos. Even the giants fight over who controls them.
The pattern: whoever holds the copyright, or a clear written license, holds the power.
What you can do
- Sellers: ask your agent who owns the photos of your home and what happens to them after the sale. There's no legitimate need for anyone to reuse them to relist your home later without the photographer's permission.
- Agents: get a written license from your photographer, and read the rights your MLS asks you to grant on upload.
- Media companies: put your license terms on every invoice and delivery, register your work with the Copyright Office, and read your MLS's photo rules.
Sources
Sources checked November 10, 2026.
- Copyright ownership and transfers: 17 U.S.C. §201 and §204.
- CRMLS license language: CRMLS Photographs and Media FAQs, 2026.
- MLS upload terms with modification and metadata rights: PFRE, March 2019.
- CRMLS photographer program and reuse permission: CRMLS photographer list.
- 2016 NAR policy language: NAR 2017 summary of MLS changes.
- November 2026 policy: NAR committee approves 4 new MLS policy changes.
- VHT v. Zillow: 9th Circuit, June 2023.
- Stross v. Redfin: 5th Circuit, No. 17-50046, April 2018.
- CoStar v. Zillow: Real Estate News, March 2026.
How we source and date figures: Respeno sourcing standards.
This post is the author’s analysis and opinion. It is not legal advice. For your own contracts, talk to a lawyer.
Free for real estate media companies
The License Terms Kit
What to put in your photo license, what NAR’s November 8 MLS copyright policy means for you, what Zillow and Aryeo take when you upload, and the disclosure laws for edited photos. Plain language, sourced, and ready to use today.
We send one confirmation email first. After that, occasional articles for media companies. Unsubscribe any time. No cookies. Privacy.