Who Pays for the Sale · Part 6 of 7
AI: Who It Really Serves
The organizations writing the rules for listing photos have invested in, or promoted, companies that alter those photos. Now that laws require disclosure, they're promoting companies that sell disclosure compliance, including one from their own investment program. They are tied to companies on both sides of the problem. The photographers who took the photos had no say in any of it.
By Kennith Wheeler, Founder, Respeno · Published November 10, 2026 · Sources checked November 10, 2026 · 4 min read
AI can make a dark room bright or stage an empty one. Used honestly and disclosed, that's fine. Enhancement is fine; deception isn't. The question this post asks is simpler: who profits from AI in the listing process, and who decided how it would work?
Side one: altering the photos
- CRMLS and Styldod. Venture MLS, a fund launched by CRMLS's leaders, invested $1 million in Styldod in 2022. CRMLS then gave its users REimagineHome, Styldod's AI staging and redesign tool, with 30 free image credits a month and "the option to purchase more."
- NAR and its REACH program. REACH is run by Second Century Ventures, NAR's wholly owned investment arm. In earlier REACH classes, companies paid a fee of up to $25,000 and gave up 1.75% to 5% equity, according to Inman; recent terms aren't public. Photo editing company BoxBrownie was in the 2018 class. AI photo company Pixlmob was in the 2025 class.
- MLS member deals. After its REACH class, BoxBrownie partnered with bridgeMLS in 2019 and with the Contra Costa and Bay East Realtor associations in 2020, offering members discounts on editing and virtual staging.
Side two: policing the photos
States started requiring disclosure of altered listing photos:
- California AB 723 took effect January 1, 2026: disclose altered photos and provide the original. AB 2025, signed September 27, 2026, extends this to rentals and fully AI-generated images, and requires a link or QR code to the original on every ad. It is expected to take effect January 1, 2027.
- Wisconsin Act 69 takes effect January 1, 2027. Metro MLS in Milwaukee began fining agents on September 1, 2026: $10, plus $10 a day, for undisclosed altered photos.
- New York, New Jersey and Washington, D.C. have bills pending.
Then the compliance products arrived:
- Coraly was chosen by the San Diego MLS to handle California's disclosure workflow: a photo scan, a proof page with a QR code, and broker review. Coraly also sells a "Listing Launch Kit" with enhanced and staged photos. It was in the first REACH Middle East class in 2026.
- NAR's own news story. On October 12, 2026, NAR published "Big tech has a fix for keeping altered listing photos more honest." It featured Coraly and named BoxBrownie and Pixlmob as REACH companies. It did not disclose that NAR's investment arm runs that program.
The same network shows up on both sides: the companies that alter the photos and the companies that check the alterations.
Side three: licensing the data
Listing photos are also valuable as data. Bright MLS's lawyers got AI chatbots to stop showing its listing photos, and Bright's leaders have said they favor licensing MLS data to AI companies. Bright and CRMLS, with Stellar MLS as a partner, run REdistribute, a joint venture that licenses listing data. CoStar's suit against Zillow alleges photos were copied to train algorithms, including the Zestimate.
NAR's November 8 package fits the same pattern. Next to the 50% copyright policy, it added new rules for MLS data feeds and for how MLS data may be used.
Whoever controls the photos controls what they're worth to AI. Nobody has offered photographers a share of that.
An open alternative
In the interest of full disclosure: I created VIDP, the Verified Image Disclosure Protocol. It's an open standard for labeling altered listing photos and linking to the original, published under a Creative Commons license. The standard and its tool are free for anyone to use, including commercially. The specification is dated April 22, 2026, and the current version of the free web tool is dated May 10, 2026, both months before NAR's article promoting paid alternatives from its own investment program.
I'm telling you that because NAR's article didn't tell you about its own ties. You can judge VIDP on its merits.
What you can do
- Buyers: look for disclosure labels and links to the original photos. If a home looks too perfect, ask for the unedited images.
- Sellers: ask your agent whether your photos were altered, and how that's disclosed.
- Agents: before you pay for a compliance product, check whether a free standard does the job, and ask who owns the company selling it.
- Media companies: keep your originals. Under California's new law, the unedited photo has to be one click away, and you're the one who holds it.
Sources
Sources checked November 8 to 10, 2026.
- Venture MLS and Styldod: PR Newswire, June 2022, RISMedia, April 2022. REimagineHome credits: CRMLS, October 2025.
- Second Century Ventures: NAR. REACH fees and equity: Inman, May 2025. BoxBrownie in REACH 2018: RISMedia.
- BoxBrownie member deals: Inman, September 2019 and BoxBrownie, May 2020.
- AB 723: The Real Deal, January 2026. AB 2025 chaptered text: Digital Democracy; the January 1, 2027 date follows California's default rule for new laws.
- Wisconsin and Metro MLS: The Close, September 2026. D.C. bill: Inman, October 2026. New York: S9584. New Jersey: A4728.
- Coraly and San Diego MLS: SDMLS. REACH Middle East: PropTech Connect, February 2026.
- NAR's article: NAR, October 12, 2026.
- Bright and AI: RISMedia, June 2026. REdistribute: Stellar MLS. CoStar v. Zillow: Real Estate News, March 2026.
- NAR November policy package: NAR, November 8, 2026.
- VIDP license, specification and tool: vidp.org (web tool v1.5.1, "Updated 2026-05-10"), specification v1.2 and changelog, April 22, 2026, the web tool.
How we source and date figures: Respeno sourcing standards.
This post is the author’s analysis and opinion. Disclosure: the author created VIDP and owns VIDP LLC. No investment terms beyond those cited are public; we don’t claim any.
Free for real estate media companies
The License Terms Kit
What to put in your photo license, what NAR’s November 8 MLS copyright policy means for you, what Zillow and Aryeo take when you upload, and the disclosure laws for edited photos. Plain language, sourced, and ready to use today.
We send one confirmation email first. After that, occasional articles for media companies. Unsubscribe any time. No cookies. Privacy.